Dear 'Gabe',
It
seems strange, in a way, writing to you. And in another way, not so
very strange at all. You were never born, yet you existed. You died,
but have lived more fully than anyone alive that I know. You didn't
have a face or a name for 5 years after your death, but now your name
and what might-have-been your face haunts me in my most quiet
moments. I can see you in my waking hours, in my son and in my own
reflection. I can see you too in the sunrise, feel you in the way my
heart swells with pride when I look at Briton - your older brother. It
has taken years to even acknowledge that I could love you. Now, your
brief, so sudden life, and death, will not leave my mind.
I don't understand why its different with you than it was, or is, with your adopted-out sister Clarisse. I
never felt a sense of ownership with her. I never let her 'belong' to
me. Now she belongs to another. But you - though you've never really
belonged to anyone except God - so many years later, your life so much
briefer, I feel an odd connection to you.
You were conceived
about a year after your sister was given up for adoption in CA. We were
still living there and your older brother Briton
was about 3 years old. I'm sorry to say that I was not happy when I
learned that I was pregnant with you. In fact, so close was it to when
your sister was born and the adoption complete, I was angry and very
scared. Though never claiming you sister emotionally or physically (I
never even wanted to hold her after her birth - she went immediately to
her adoptive parents), still the pregnancy and adoption process were
trying and traumatic. Your father's and my families had had no
knowledge of her whatsoever. In fact, we'd left for CA from MD barely a
few days before it became very obvious that I was pregnant. We'd
driven across country with your then 2 yr. old brother Briton. We'd
gotten 'stuck' in Albuquerque, NM for a few weeks due to car trouble, but
finally made itr to CA where we lived with the adoptive parents for the
duration of that pregnancy and her birth. Living with them and
constantly being aware
of the baby's impending adoption was hard despite the fact that they
are very kind and generous people. To me, it was a relief to birth her,
to sign her over, and be out on our own again, though I never allowed
myself to acknowledge any emotional attachment to her whatsoever. Even
now. And quite honestly, I don't want to - as horrible as some may
think it.
We'd found an apartment and while things were now
supposed to be 'perfect', our plans to prosper in lovely central CA,
tings were not. I sunk into a deep, anxiety-high depression and wanted,
more than anything else, to escape from myself and any recognition of
what I had done and become. I had very little contact with my family
and no friends. So - when I heard t hat I was pregnant AGAIN, it was
more than I coudl bear. My memories of those first weeks are vague, but
I believe we saw the doctor to question abortion. Your father did not
approve, but did not know how to confront me on it or communicate his
feelings. I was desperate and afraid. So one night I cried out to God,
whom I still believed in but was not following. I told Him, "God, I
know you hate me, for who I am, all I've done, and what I've become.
But how could you do this again? How could you let me get pregnant
again? For this child's sake and for mine? I CAN'T go through this
again! So just take it back! Take 'it' back! "It" was you Gabe...
Hmm... I interrupt myself... I've gotten this
far before... A recitation of the facts, a list of events that
happened. Maybe not SIMPLE to relay, but, relayed. For all the
difficulties already lying therein, the story has an even deeper and
more hurtful side... No point in pausing now I suppose, there was a
little more yet of the tale that I've spoken before...
The next morning, or maybe it was a day or two later - my mind was hazy on time then at best - I got up and was bleeding, cramping pretty horribly. I expelled a large clot into the toilet. I don't know what I was expecting to see, but it looked as though the 'clot' had a knot of gray tissue at its center. I called the hospital, asked if there was someone I could talk to about it, ask what was happening... but I knew. I've never really been stupid. Foolish. Not a 'quick study' one might say. Naive. Selfish.. a thousand more adjectives, take your pick. But I knew. And eventually, I found someone kind enough at the hospital to tell me honestly. Yeah, that's a miscarriage. That's a baby in your toilet. I was uncertain what to feel... Relief felt so cold somehow. But there was some of that. But I think easily the strongest emotion was certainty. I KNEW that I had just killed my child. It wasn't a 'clean' death, by a dr. in some dr.'s office. But the result had certainly been the same... Surprised maybe, a little? That God had actually heard me when I hadn't been given a sign (or so I thought then) of a response from Him before? That the first sign of a response from Him in my life had been such a cold one? Yeah. That too. You see, it wasn't enough that I had considered abortion, that I had considered it once before, but given the child away instead. This time, I had killed my child, of all things, with a PRAYER. How - utterly - despicable.
See, Gabe, I had never really stopped believing in God... I'd known He existed from the time I was old enough to say 'Yesus.' I can't remember a time when I did NOT know that He existed. Even in those years I've just been relaying when I hated Him, when I wanted nothing more than to hide from Him, run away from Him, get as far away as possible from Him, make believe - insist even to my own heart - that He had never wanted or meant me to be His. Still, I knew He was there. And just before I had begun the full-blown running period, in fact, I had issued Him a challenge. 'Okay God,' I'd prayed. 'If there's EVER been any truth to the words that You love me, (and you certainly haven't been showing it or stooping down to help me, to get me away from my mother, to stop her from hurting me, to stop my father from dying and leaving me with her, to let me stay with my aunt - the only person who ever really believed in me and wanted me around - to help me be good enough at something, to let me at least do something half-way as good as my perfect siblings, to do anything for me when I needed you the most) then You can come after me.' Well... He DID come after me. But only after subjecting me to the very worst of my worst enemy. Not my mother, not death, not dad's memory of a cold foreign body in a box that was missing my dad's 'self', not the constant questioning of everyone in my life of, 'When will you measure up?', not even the devil. Myself. And with this "first" direct response, to a prayer to 'take it back', He was showing me that He DID exist and WAS listening...
Well, there it was then. There was my answer. Yes, He was there. Yes, at least for a few moments, He was paying attention. Yeah. I had just become a murderer.... What further confirmation did I need that all of those people in my life had been right? That I was disgusting, doomed to failure, and would NEVER come close to being what others were. Would always be a disappointment, and a failure. See, I thought that I could prove them wrong by running away and doing my own thing. Instead... I had only managed to prove them right. I had never been more sure of that than in that moment when I knew I had prayed you to death. Not even when I gave your sister away...
You would think that that was rock bottom. Finally. But it wasn't. Not really. There were several more years of hell. I won't relay them all here, but having to leave California and my big, illusory dreams of happiness and love, living with your father's family and being blamed for all the wrong things he and I had done - by his family as well as my own, living through your father's 'confession' of the unspeakable secret - that your sister had existed and been given away, the social worker visit, the custody fight and terror of losing your brother Briton, the worst terror I'd ever known, being called clinically unstable... just to name a few. But that's not where things progressed in the story of you. In fact, it wasn't for several more YEARS that I even thought of you again in more than a passing way... And then it was because I began feeling this nagging sense in the back of my mind of guilt. I was familiar with guilt alright, but this seemed somehow different. My life and Briton's too were certainly different. He and I had our own place. We lived close to my sister and your uncle and two cousins (Bryce came along later). I was working and holding down a job, trying to learn how to pay bills and be responsible, something I'd never had an example of before. We... were back to following God, desperately clinging to Him in fact, and in a church that was a place I'd only IMAGINED existed before. A place that we'd both always needed. A home - a placed called 'West Shore Evangelical Free'. I'd met not just one person, but several, who managed to convince me that true Christian love - and forgiveness - existed. Went to a Ladies Bible Study or two. Told much of my story to a Sunday school group of people that I didn't know well. Cried when I did too. Even made a few actual friends. And one of those friends decided to pay for me to come to a Women's Retreat, even though I didn't really want to go... Never having really liked gatherings of women she had to work pretty hard to convince me to go. :p Cry groups, that sort of thing. Then went to my 2nd Women's Retreat where a very nice Christian speaker was speaking. She began to tell us all about how she'd had a miscarriage and how much that had hurt, and there the twinge started becoming painful.
The speaker went on, of course, in her story, talked about the daughter she had with special needs and the other hard things she'd been through. But I was still stuck back there at her miscarriage and how devastated s he'd been... My persistent lady friend, Cindy, decided go buy me one of this speaker's books about her miscarriage. I was quite honestly afraid to read it, but during one of our quiet times, I did crack it open, and... I was right. It was there in print. "I was angry," This mother wrote of her miscarriage. "There were so many other young, irresponsible mothers who just didn't care anything at all about their babies lives, who got abortions to get rid of something they'd never wanted and never thought about that child again, young women who just didn't care. I had done everything right. I had tried to lead a good Christian life. Married a Christian man, raised other Christian children... I prayed and prayed for this child to live. And it died anyway." Those aren't exact quotes... But what had been stirring in my gut now had its clear face, and a name. Shame. How many other wonderful Christian women who DID do everything write, who blamed themselves for some mysterious mistake anyway while being perfectly innocent, who prayed and begged and pleased with God to keep their children, had lost them anyway? ... And which one of them could possibly NOT have had moments of the same blatant accusation against the rest of us who did NOT want their own pregnancies? Even worse, those women and their accusations were, in large part, right. Or... at least so I believed at the time. To me, it was another nail hammered into the scarred and still bleeding casket of my heart. Yeah, I really HAD been that evil, that much of a disappointment, that rebellious little girl that had I'd always been... A child who had never measured up and had become a murderer through a prayer. All those nice, good Christian women who'd done everything right and pleaded for their children's lives and still lost them... And I'd prayed for God to take it back, and He'd listened...
I spent an afternoon crying with my friend, not really understanding how to put the shame into words, something that was INCREDIBLY frustrating for me because always before, words had been my gift, my way of expressing those feelings which I couldn't otherwise figure out how to communicate. I guess she must have understood enough of what I was saying to assure me, "You didn't kill your baby." It was polite, and kind of her to say... but I didn't really believe her. I'm STILL not sure that I do... in fact, I might as well admit, I still don't... I love her. And I trust her in most other matters, even when we don't completely agree. But... *sigh* Yeah, I still think she's wrong. But at that time, since I had managed to get across what was bothering me, I couldn't do any more than that, and so we headed back to our room. "He did have a name you know." I said, just before we went back inside. "His name was Gabriel Josiah." She smiled at me kindly and said, 'Thank you for sharing.' Well, at least now, you had a name...
(have to take a short break)
After that, I - there have been glimpses of the hurt... But I think for the most part I swallowed these things again, dreading bringing them to light once more for examination like a princess dreading bringing a horribly diseased secret from her pocket to examine it in the light... One particularly painful period was when my sister gave birth to her 3rd child, Bryce... Then, it was just an awareness of extreme sadness that I couldn't understand... But I loved that little baby - my nephew. :) Love him still. Today I spent part of an afternoon with him and his sister playing in the fall leaves in fact.... I remember NEEDING to show that baby to Briton in the hospital room, having Briton hold him (which he did, shyly of course.)
You know Gabe, I know this is a little off-track, but just recently when this all started coming up again, I think that maybe why I don't seem to have much regret or emotional attachment to your sister Clarisse and her adoption and I DO with you is because Clarisse is so easy to justify. No, I didn't want her, not at that time anyway. But Clarisse I see happy, smiling pictures of, and I KNOW she's in a good, loving home with people that will always want and care about her. Even if I gave her away selfishly too (yeah - figure that one out why don't you), she ended up in a good place. You, however, ended up as a grayish blob of flesh floating in a toilet...
Back on track, just within the past few months, I've been thinking more and more about you again... It seems to come in stages, maybe my minds way of dealing with someone excruciating that I can't take in all at once. Somehow, it seems, I've taken on that shame and guilt about what happened to you and attached it to people that I do know have wanted children and lost them... In one way, it doesn't make sense, especially because with some of these women, I've really shared no more than a few words - maybe not even that. I don't know them. They don't know me, and they CERTAINLY don't know about you and what I did to you... And yet somehow, I feel beneath them. I feel like they must hate me, SHOULD hate me, WOULD hate me if they knew - and that would only be right. Its just so unfair. They DID do everything right. They were good mothers. They knew HOW to be good mothers and to love their children in a Godly way. I've never really had a clear sense of how to do that - though I try so DESPERATELY to be a good mom to Briton... My mother loves me and always has, but she set such a poor example of how to love your children well... It left me little to work with in terms of example of being a good Godly mom... Now, I can only look at other mothers, yes some of those ones who I now feel only shame around, and try to figure out what they know that I don't, how they 'do things right' with the kids they do have and have raised...
Its interesting, one such mother I do know pretty well - and love very dearly actually. I feel jealous that her kids had, and have her as a mom. And while I do feel some shame (though I don't know that I'd tell her to her face), I have NEVER felt blamed. Such a beautiful lady...
And then there's another... one I DON'T know well at all, although I DO or --- I guess I should say I USED to know the father very well.... For whatever reason (I'm sure if one were to have the patience and wherewithal to unravel the convoluted mess of circumstances for it they could figure it out) I've begun to feel absolutely SURE must hate me for your death. Somehow that shame has attached to her and I become that shame - it attaches to my heart whenever I see her face... or his really too. They'll be gone soon... but I know the shame won't go away with them... And the poor man (who at one time knew me so well) simply has no clue why I can't look him, or his wife, in the eye anymore... Though, I suppose, it is fortunate that he has other reasons for not wanting to...
....
I'm told that... I need to work on correcting faulty thinking... to not think of your death as a horrible, disgusting tragedy, but rather as God extending Hism ercy to me, and to you Gabe, in a time when we really shouldn't have been together - you shouldn't have been born.. My head tells me there's some truth in that... That same person also is the one who suggested I write this letter to you... I had already been thinking of writing a letter to those 'miscarriage moms' expressing my shame and apologies too. But I think they were right too in that I needed to write to you. Clearly, I'm writing to you first.
.....
You know uh... there's been so much more going on in my life these past few weeks than just this hurting concern over you, but somehow now as I think of you and struggle to begin the next step in 'recovery' over this, instead of empty platitudes or some sort of undeserved comfort, I hear the words ringing in my mind of an old hymn...
Blessed assurance, Jesus is mine...
Oh what a foretaste of glory divine...
Heir of salvation, purchase of God
Born of His Spirit
Washed in His blood...
This is my story, This is my song
Praising my Savior all the day long
This is my story, this is my song
Praising my savior all the day long
Perfect submission, perfect delight!
Visions of rapture now burst on my sight;
Angels descending bring from above
Echoes of mercy, whispers of love.
Perfect submission, all is at rest!
I in my Savior am happy and blest,
Watching and waiting, looking above,
Filled with His goodness, lost in His love.
This is my story, This is my song
Praising my Savior all the day long
This is my story, this is my song
Praising my savior all the day long...
******************************************************************************
(Not sure if I'm done with this yet or not, but... need to find something much more 'mindless' to do for a little bit... Pray I'll be brave enough to go to church tomorrow...)